That is an version of The Atlantic Each day, a publication that guides you thru the most important tales of the day, helps you uncover new concepts, and recommends the perfect in tradition. Join it right here.
Ask Trump supporters why they just like the president, and likelihood is good you’ll hear one thing like: He tells it like it’s and says what he means. The query, then, is why so lots of them refused to take him at his phrase. Over the primary three weeks of the second Trump presidency, a recurrent motif is that Trump does precisely what he stated he would, after which individuals who backed him react with shock and dismay.
In case you’re stunned, you weren’t paying consideration—and judging from current examples, many individuals weren’t. When Trump introduced his plan (I’m utilizing the phrase generously) to occupy the Gaza Strip and convert it into a global real-estate improvement, the chairman of Arab People for Trump, which fashioned to again him in the course of the election, expressed shock and betrayal, and introduced that the group would rename itself Arab People for Peace. Some Arab American voters might have felt compelled to lodge a protest vote in opposition to Joe Biden’s dealing with of the warfare in Gaza, even when it meant contributing to Trump’s win, however nobody ought to have been stunned {that a} man who used Palestinian as an insult in the course of the marketing campaign was not a honest champion for the folks of Gaza.
Some Venezuelan People in Florida are feeling related outrage. Trump continued to make features with Hispanic voters in 2024, however this month he ended Momentary Protected Standing, a designation that permits noncitizens to remain within the nation, for about 300,000 Venezuelans, with extra TPS designees more likely to lose their standing later. “They used us,” the Venezuelan activist Adelys Ferro instructed NPR. “Throughout the marketing campaign, the elected officers from the Republican Celebration, they really instructed us that he was not going to the touch the documented folks. They stated, ‘No, it’s with undocumented folks.’” In truth, each Trump and Vice President J. D. Vance stated they wished to deport folks legally allowed within the nation, equivalent to Haitians in Springfield, Ohio. Some voters simply satisfied themselves that their very own teams wouldn’t change into targets.
They’re not alone. Some Kentucky educators who voted for Trump are aghast that his administration is attempting to minimize off federal funding that they should preserve their colleges functioning, regardless of his campaign-trail guarantees to abolish the Division of Schooling. “I didn’t vote for that,” one principal instructed CNN. “I voted for President Trump to make America first once more and to enhance our lives.” The Fraternal Order of Police, the nation’s largest police union, endorsed Trump for president, then decried Trump’s resolution to pardon January 6 rioters who attacked cops—by no means thoughts that he had promised pardons whereas campaigning. CEOs and bankers who determined they favored Trump higher as a result of he favors low taxes and fewer regulation are all of a sudden chagrined to study that he was severe about tariffs. A Missouri farmer who voted for Trump is horrified that the administration is freezing federal funding for conservation applications, though Trump promised to remove environmental applications and slash authorities spending.
All of this was foreseeable. In a 2015 tweet that continues to be depressingly related a decade later, Adrian Bott joked: “‘I by no means thought leopards would eat MY face,’ sobs girl who voted for the Leopards Consuming Folks’s Faces Celebration.” However I don’t wish to single out abnormal residents. Even Republican members of Congress are doing the identical dance—cheering on Trump cuts on the whole however scrambling to guard their very own states from dropping any federal cash. They ran for workplace with the Leopards Consuming Folks’s Faces Celebration, however they by no means anticipated the leopards to eat their faces too.
Different Trump guarantees have been fairly doubtful in case you listened to the remainder of his plans. “Beginning on day one, we are going to finish inflation and make America reasonably priced once more,” he stated. However Trump’s signature marketing campaign concepts have been massive tariffs and mass deportation. Each of those are inflationary: Tariffs increase the worth of products, and mass deportation makes labor scarcer, elevating salaries, which in flip drives costs larger. Right now, the Federal Reserve launched the primary Client Value Index replace of Trump’s time period, discovering 3 % inflation. That’s a hair above economists’ expectations however in keeping with final month’s figures. Persistent inflation shouldn’t come as a shock to anybody, and never solely due to the sharp rise in egg costs, pushed by chicken flu, that my colleague Lora Kelley lined final week.
You don’t want an economics diploma to foretell this. You simply needed to heed the many warnings about it, which even Fox Information lined. Or you may simply hearken to what Trump stated, as when he advised that tariffs would pay for youngster care or that Biden’s encouragement of wind energy was accountable for inflation. These aren’t simply the sorts of comforting nonsense all politicians generally peddle; they’re incoherent. Since successful the election, he has downplayed his inflation guarantees and introduced a set of tariffs that, though not totally felt but, might already be edging costs larger. Now Trump desires the Fed to drop rates of interest, which might stimulate the economic system—and sure enhance inflation.
When Trump ran for president in 2016, uncertainty about his seriousness was comprehensible. He was a legendary service provider of hyperbole, and nobody was certain the place his persona ended and his actual political intentions started. No such excuse applies anymore—as I identified in September, Trump was president as soon as, and he tried to maintain most of his large guarantees, albeit typically ineffectively. This time round, Trump stated he was going to do this stuff—and hey, he tells it like it’s.
Associated:
Listed here are three new tales from The Atlantic:
Right now’s Information
- Trump spoke with Russian President Vladimir Putin and mentioned coming into negotiations to finish the warfare in Ukraine.
- Former Consultant Tulsi Gabbard was confirmed because the director of nationwide intelligence.
- Marc Fogel, an American schoolteacher who had been wrongfully detained in Russia since 2021, was launched from jail and landed within the U.S. final evening.
Night Learn
The Tesla Revolt
By Patrick George
Donald Trump could also be happy sufficient with Elon Musk, however even because the Tesla CEO is exercising his newfound energy to basically undo complete features of the federal authorities, he nonetheless has to reassure his traders. These days, Musk has delivered for them in a technique: The worth of the corporate’s shares has skyrocketed since Trump was reelected to the presidency of america. However Musk had a lot to reply for on his current fourth-quarter earnings name—not least that in 2024, Tesla’s automotive gross sales had sunk for the primary time in a decade.
Extra From The Atlantic
Tradition Break
Learn. Decide up certainly one of these seven books whenever you wish to stop.
Play. A radical tweak makes the online game Civilization extra sensible—and extra miserable, Spencer Kornhaber writes.
P.S.
After I’m not writing about politics, I prefer to moonlight as The Atlantic’s jazz author. One among today, I wish to profile the tenor saxophonist James Brandon Lewis, who I believe will be the most dynamic determine in jazz at the moment. He launched a brand new album, Apple Cores, on Friday, and it’s usually wonderful—which is to say, it’s wonderful and likewise not beholden to any explicit kind. Like Sonny Rollins, a transparent inspiration, Lewis makes music that’s adventurous and difficult however doesn’t require a deep immersion in jazz to understand. I particularly like “Prince Eugene,” which is pushed by the percussionist Chad Taylor’s hypnotic mbira riff.
— David
Stephanie Bai contributed to this article.
Discover all of our newsletters right here.
If you purchase a e-book utilizing a hyperlink on this publication, we obtain a fee. Thanks for supporting The Atlantic.
